Hellow guys, Welcome to my website, and you are watching Ask Ian - What Was the Best WW2 Rifle Cartridge?. and this vIdeo is uploaded by Forgotten Weapons at 2022-08-04T05:00:37-07:00. We are pramote this video only for entertainment and educational perpose only. So, I hop you like our website.
| Name | Ask Ian - What Was the Best WW2 Rifle Cartridge? |
| Video Uploader | Video From Forgotten Weapons |
| Upload Date | This Video Uploaded At 04-08-2022 12:00:37 |
| Video Discription | https://utreon.com/c/forgottenweapons/ http://www.patreon.com/ForgottenWeapons http://www.floatplane.com/channel/ForgottenWeapons Cool Forgotten Weapons merch! http://shop.forgottenweapons.com The shirt is from Otte Gear, since so many people asked last time: https://ottegear.com/collections/lifestyle/products/aloha-fal-shirt From crablegs21 on Utreon: "In your opinion and in hindsight, which country had the most optimized cartridge for the their primary infantry rifle for WWII? Additionally, which country would have benefited most by switching to that cartridge prior to WWII?" In my opinion - and I think post-war development supports this - the best rifle cartridge was 8mm Kurz (7.92x33mm). The StG-44 was never actually Germany's primary infantry rifle, but they wanted it to be. The 8mm Kurz offers much reduced recoil ideal for semiauto and select-fire rifles, allowing fast followup shots while remaining powerful enough to be quite deadly. However, this doesn't address the logistical issue of machine gun cartridges. Basically everyone in WW2 used a single cartridge for both rifles and support machine guns, and the cartridge choice was largely dictated by what was most effective in a machine gun intended to shoot out to 1000+ yards and to engage vehicles and aircraft. Larger cartridges were much better suited for this than today's intermediate cartridges. Interestingly, both the Italians (6.5mm Carcano) and the Swedes (6.5mm Swedish) developed supplemental big machine gun cartridges because they considered their standard rounds insufficient (these were 8x59mm for the Italians and 8x63mm for the Swedes) If I had to pick a larger cartridge to allow both rifle and MG use, I would pick 7.35mm Carcano. This is about the lightest "rifle" round of the war that used a spitzer bullet and a rimless case. Its larger bullet diameter compared to 6.5mm rounds would allow better tracer and AP bullets, which are relevant in a military context. As for which nation could benefit the most from adopting this cartridge before the war, I will go out on a limb and say the US, at least form a rifleman's perspective. The M1 Garand chambered for 7.35mm Carcano would be a fantastic rifle, probably at least a pound lighter than normal and faster shooting. The BAR could be lightened much more, and might have been able to be a more truly effective automatic rifle. Contact: Forgotten Weapons 6281 N. Oracle 36270 Tucson, AZ 85740 |
| Category | Education |
| Tags | history | development | mccollum | forgotten weapons | design | disassembly | rifle | cartridge | best cartridge | best ww2 | best ww2 cartridge | ww2 | world war | World War Two | German | American | british | italian | Japanese | 30-06 | 8mm mauser | 8mm kurz | 8x33 | 6.5 jap | 6.5 Carcano | 7.35 Carcano | 6.5x50 | 6.5x55 | 6.5 swede | Carcano | q&a | question | answer | ask Ian | 30 carbine | 303 | 303 british | 7.62 russian | 7.62x54r |
